First posted on LinkedIn on 3 November 2026 by Nick Dunse, Chief Revenue Officer at Shuttle. Edited here on 16 November 2026 to match the sources.
Approving a payment plan by software can still count as automated decision-making, even when the answer is yes.
That's the Dutch data protection regulator, in a report on collection agencies that a Dutch accountancy news site covered on 30 October.
It surveyed 29 agencies and 22 gave usable answers. Of those 22, ten use at least one algorithmic system, and three of the ten use AI. At some agencies, automated contact (chatbots, phone systems, email) can end in a fully automated payment agreement. Some said software only approves, and anything it would turn down goes to a person.
That sounds like the careful way to build it. The regulator says a yes doesn't take a decision out of the GDPR rule. In principle, the GDPR bans automated decisions that significantly affect the debtor, unless an exception applies. The regulator also thinks agencies may be making automated decisions without realising. And most of them buy the software rather than build it.
I'm not a lawyer, and this is the Dutch reading of the GDPR, nothing wider. But if I were building a voice or chat agent that agrees plans, I'd want the creditor to write the terms down first, the agent to offer only what's inside them, and a record of what was offered and what was agreed. That's what I'd build, not compliance advice.
If you build collections software, who sets the terms in yours, you or your customer?
Sources
Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, "AP informeert incassobureaus over verantwoorde inzet AI" (29 Oct 2026)
Accountant.nl, "AP waarschuwt voor risico's bij inzet AI door incassobureaus" (30 Oct 2026)