When Your SaaS Outgrows Stripe Connect: A Migration Playbook

The Stripe Connect Growth Trap

Stripe Connect is the best way to start embedding payments in a SaaS platform. The docs are excellent, the developer experience is unmatched, and you can go from zero to processing in days.

Nobody should feel bad about starting with Stripe Connect. Most platforms do, and it's the right call.

The problem isn't starting with Stripe. It's staying with Stripe when your platform and your merchants' needs have moved beyond what a single PSP can serve.

This isn't a Stripe-bashing piece. Stripe is excellent at what it does. But Stripe is a PSP — and a PSP's incentive is to process every transaction through its own rails. That alignment works until your merchants' needs diverge from Stripe's coverage.

Five Signs You've Outgrown Stripe Connect

1. Enterprise Customers Mandate Their Own PSP

This is the most common trigger. An enterprise prospect says: "We already have a Worldpay contract. We need you to process through Worldpay."

With Stripe Connect, the answer is no. Every transaction routes through Stripe's acquiring network. There is no mechanism to process through a third-party PSP.

For early-stage platforms, this rarely matters. For platforms selling into enterprise — where merchants have existing banking relationships, negotiated rates, and compliance requirements that mandate specific acquirers — it becomes a deal-breaker.

The pattern: You lose one enterprise deal because of PSP inflexibility. Then a second. By the third, the question escalates from "can we support this?" to "how much revenue are we leaving on the table?"

2. You're Expanding Into Geographies Stripe Doesn't Cover Well

Stripe operates in 46+ countries. That's impressive — until your platform needs to serve merchants in markets where Stripe's coverage is thin or its acquiring rates aren't competitive.

Middle East, parts of Africa, Southeast Asia, and several Latin American markets either lack Stripe coverage or require local acquirers for competitive interchange rates. If your platform is expanding internationally, you need PSPs that have local acquiring relationships in those markets.

A single-PSP architecture makes this impossible. You'd need to build separate integrations for each regional acquirer — which is exactly the multi-PSP problem you were trying to avoid.

3. You Need Payment Channels Beyond Online Checkout

Stripe Connect handles online checkout and mobile payments. It does this very well.

But platforms increasingly need payments across more surfaces:

• Voice payments — contact centres taking PCI-compliant payments over the phone

• Payment links — branded checkout pages sent via SMS, email, or chat

• AI agent payments — voice or chat agents processing payments mid-conversation

• Pay-by-bank — direct account-to-account payments (Open Banking)

Stripe has introduced some of these (Stripe Payment Links, for example), but they route through Stripe's rails with Stripe's branding. If you need white-label payment links your merchants can brand as their own, or PCI-compliant voice payments for a contact centre, Stripe Connect doesn't cover it.

4. Stripe's Fees Are Eating Your Revenue Share

Stripe Connect's pricing is transparent: 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction, plus $2 per active connected account per month, plus additional fees for payouts, identity verification, and Connect Onboarding.

For platforms taking a revenue share (application fees), Stripe's base rate sits underneath — meaning the platform's margin is what's left after Stripe's cut.

As transaction volume grows, platforms often discover they can negotiate significantly better rates with alternative PSPs. But with Stripe Connect, switching means rebuilding — not renegotiating.

The lock-in isn't technical (Stripe's APIs are clean). It's architectural: every merchant, every transaction, every webhook, every reconciliation flow is built around Stripe's data model.

5. Your Merchants Have Systems That Need to Connect

Enterprise merchants don't operate in isolation. They have ERP systems, accounting platforms, CRM workflows, and existing payment infrastructure that needs to interoperate.

When a merchant says "we need our transactions to reconcile with our Worldpay settlement reports" or "our ERP only integrates with Adyen," Stripe Connect can't help. The merchant's systems expect data from their PSP — not from yours.

This is the reality most SaaS platforms discover as they move upmarket: merchants have existing payment ecosystems, and your platform needs to fit into them — not replace them.

Why This Isn't Just a Stripe Problem

To be clear: this isn't unique to Stripe. Adyen for Platforms has the same constraint — every transaction routes through Adyen. Checkout.com, Square, any PSP-owned platform solution locks you into that PSP.

The issue is the model: PSP-owned platform solutions are designed to grow the PSP's transaction volume, not to give platforms PSP flexibility.

This works when your merchants don't care which PSP processes their transactions. It breaks when they do.

And the further upmarket you go, the more merchants care.

The Migration Decision Framework

Don't migrate if:

• All your merchants are happy with Stripe. If no one is asking for an alternative PSP, you don't have this problem yet.

• You're not selling into enterprise. SMB merchants rarely mandate specific PSPs.

• You only operate in Stripe's strongest markets. US, UK, EU, Australia — Stripe's coverage is excellent.

• You don't need non-checkout payment channels. If online checkout is your only surface, Stripe Connect handles it well.

Start planning a migration when:

• You've lost (or nearly lost) a deal because of PSP inflexibility. This is the clearest signal.

• Geographic expansion is on the roadmap. You'll need regional acquirers sooner than you think.

• Voice, links, or AI payments are on the roadmap. These channels need PSP-neutral infrastructure.

• Stripe's fees are compressing your margins. And you can't negotiate because you're locked in.

Migration doesn't mean ripping out Stripe

The most common migration pattern is additive, not replacement:

1. Keep Stripe as one PSP. Merchants already on Stripe stay on Stripe.

2. Add a payment layer above Stripe. The payment layer sits between your platform and all PSPs — including Stripe.

3. New merchants choose their PSP. Enterprise merchants connect their own gateway. Others default to Stripe (or whichever PSP offers the best rates for their geography).

4. Add new channels through the payment layer. Voice, links, AI — without building separate integrations.

This approach preserves your existing Stripe integration, eliminates merchant migration risk, and gives you multi-PSP flexibility going forward.

What a Payment Layer Gives You

The Migration Process

Phase 1: Parallel Operation (Week 1-2)

• Integrate the payment layer alongside your existing Stripe Connect setup

• Configure Stripe as one PSP within the payment layer

• New merchants onboard through the payment layer (defaulting to Stripe)

• Existing merchants continue on Stripe Connect unchanged

Phase 2: Enterprise Enablement (Week 3-4)

• Configure additional PSPs as needed (Worldpay, Adyen, regional acquirers)

• Enable enterprise merchants to connect their mandated PSP

• Add new payment channels (voice, links) through the payment layer

• Begin routing new enterprise deals through the multi-PSP setup

Phase 3: Gradual Migration (Months 2-6)

• Migrate existing merchants to the payment layer as contracts renew

• Some merchants stay on Stripe (via the payment layer). That's fine.

• Others move to preferred PSPs based on geography or rates

• Platform gains full PSP flexibility without disrupting any merchant

Timeline: Weeks, Not Quarters

The integration work is a single API integration — your platform talks to the payment layer, the payment layer talks to every PSP. This is fundamentally different from building 5 individual PSP integrations.

Most platforms go live with a payment layer in 2-4 weeks. The migration of existing merchants happens gradually, merchant by merchant, with zero downtime.

FAQ

Will my existing Stripe merchants be disrupted?

No. In a properly architected migration, Stripe remains as one PSP within the payment layer. Existing merchants continue processing through Stripe with no change to their experience. The difference is that new merchants (and migrating merchants) can choose alternative PSPs.

Can I still use Stripe's features (Radar, Billing, etc.)?

Stripe-specific features are tied to Stripe's ecosystem. Fraud tools like Radar work when transactions route through Stripe. For transactions routed through other PSPs, equivalent capabilities are available through the payment layer or the PSP itself.

What about my Stripe Connect webhooks?

The payment layer provides unified webhooks across all PSPs. You'll migrate from Stripe-specific webhook handling to PSP-agnostic event handling — which simplifies your codebase (one handler instead of one per PSP).

How much does this cost compared to Stripe Connect?

Payment layer pricing is typically transaction-based. For platforms currently paying Stripe's Connect fees (2.9% + $0.30 + $2/account/month), the total cost is often comparable or lower — especially when factoring in better rates available through alternative PSPs for high-volume merchants.

What if we want to come back to Stripe Connect later?

You're not leaving Stripe. Stripe remains a supported PSP. You're adding flexibility on top. There's nothing to "come back" to.

Related Reading

• Shuttle vs Stripe Connect — the detailed feature comparison

• Stripe Connect Alternatives for Platforms — the full landscape of alternatives

• Shuttle vs Adyen for Platforms — same single-PSP problem, different provider

• How Platforms Monetise Payments Without PSP Lock-In — why PSP-neutral architecture unlocks more revenue

• How to Get Payments Off Your Product Roadmap — the hidden cost of maintaining payment infrastructure

• Shuttle vs Building In-House — the real cost of building payment infrastructure yourself

Ready to move beyond single-PSP limitations?

See how platforms use Shuttle to keep Stripe while adding 40+ PSPs, voice payments, and enterprise PSP flexibility — in weeks.

Talk to Us | See How It Works